Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Brian Lumley.com Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Brian Lumley.com

Mass Debate

Featured Replies

  • Author

I always felt that Trask was just making up for going against Harry, he always seemed like he was doing it all out of duty and he just wanted to finish the work that others had started.

 

I like Ben Trask but I still don't think he was the main man, it doesn't really mention it in the books but I always got the impression that he was carrying a secret guilt and burden around with himself, and that he kind of felt partly responsible about what happened to Harry,

and because of that he has never and will never be my favourite.

  • Replies 216
  • Views 33.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'd say Alec Kyle, for one and most obvious, Harry later inhabits his body making it his own, without which Harry may have just passed on into the Great Majority, or wherever he may have gone in that state, and none of the events of The Source, Deadspeak, DeadSpawn, The Lost Years, and the big one of course. Nathan and Nestor not being conceived. Would have happened if it wasn't for Kyle.

 

Also, he created the file on Harry Keogh that all future members of E-branch read to familiarise themselves with what Harry is about. If I remember in the last three E-branch books, they give out the file for mandatory reading to the new members. Without Alec Kyle to write down tale Harry tells him in his incorporeal form, the tale that Tran descends time, as a lot of it hadn't already happened, or was just happening when Harry was informing Kyle. Things may have turned out a lot differently in the world, What if Yulian Bodescu was not stopped, simply because Harry hadn't of told E-branch about him?

 

But I could be talking crap... but there is my answer anyway,

 

Sophie

 

[ March 28, 2004, 04:27 PM: Message edited by: Sophie ]

Some good points about Kyle there but I don't agree that having a body going spare means that you've done anything more valuable, even though he did do many things that were good before his mind was wiped out, like begining to unite the Russians and the British, it was just very fortunate for Harry that things happened that way.

 

OK, if things hadn't have happened that way then thre would not have been any of Harry's offspring in Starside but it was just circumstancial, Alec didn't give Harry his body, Harry took it.

 

Helm, maybe Trask did feel the burden of what he did to Harry, but he didn't do any different than anyone else, and was better than some, and he tried his best to make it up to Nathan and I think he succeeded.

 

Being burdend by duty doesn't make you any less valuable either. One of the things that made him so great was that he did that duty and what he thought was right no matter what was going on with him personally, he put the team first and the human race every time.

Originally posted by Silver:

Some good points about Kyle there but I don't agree that having a body going spare means that you've done anything more valuable, even though he did do many things that were good before his mind was wiped out, like begining to unite the Russians and the British, it was just very fortunate for Harry that things happened that way.

OK, if things hadn't have happened that way then thre would not have been any of Harry's offspring in Starside but it was just circumstancial, Alec didn't give Harry his body, Harry took it.

Whether or not Kyle gave his body to Harry or he took it isn't the point, even without his mind, his body was valuable, because without it Harry wouldn't have been able to carry on. Maybe it was just circumstantial, it stilled saved Harry's neck by those chain of events. For me Kyle did a lot more things before being brain washed and left a husk as I pointed out.

 

I do like Ben trask(he was second on my list, and Lupa made a point that E-branch was a team past and present and it's very hard to choose just one person who was the most valuable) and he was one of the main character throughout the whole linking series. I like him as much as everybody else does, but I just feel Alec contributed (before being brain washed and after when he was just a body) quite a big important part of the continuation of the story. But it would be a bit boring debate if everybody agreed with everybody tongue.gif

 

Sophie

 

[ March 31, 2004, 11:14 AM: Message edited by: Sophie ]

  • Author

Right looks like we've gone over on this one but I didn't want to spoil it as this little poser seemed to generate a little more interest than some of its predecessors.

 

I don't think any one member of E-Branch could be picked out in the end, but I guess that's why they say there’s no I in TEAM.

 

As for the overall Mass-Debater on this little subject I'm going to have to award my mate Shaz with the honour (Silver for anyone that doesn't know)

 

Pick us a good-un

Thanks Helm, but you know your mistake don't you? Or did you do it on purpose?

 

Anyway, back to topic - it's really difficult to think of something!

 

OK we've just had the most valuable member of Ebranch, but who has the most valuable/useful talent in Ebranch, excluding Harry or Jake obviously.

  • Author

Right I've had a good old think about this one and believe that I have the perfect answer, you see it strikes me the all the talents in e-branch are pretty even.

All of them are equally useful especially when they are doubled up or even combined as a whole.

 

So with this in mind I've approached this question from a slightly different angle and I'm going to base it on the talent with the least draw back, you see every talent is useful but they all have there little draw backs as well.

 

Darcy Clarke for instance, now his guardian angel would be an awesome talent to have, but it’s not the most useful thing to a team now is it, he’s hardly going to be a big help to you in a scrap now is he, as he’s likely to be giving it toes in the opposite direction while your getting your head kicked in.

 

Ben Trask human lie detector, obviously a really useful talent but after a while it must start to really bring you down and make you bitter as the whole world seems to be lying.

 

Zek/Jordan etc and there telepathy another awesome talent and probably one of the front runners, a huge talent with a huge draw back with there minds so open it leaves them wide open for counter attack.

 

Ian Goodly’s precognistic ability is really useful but it doesn’t really change anything does it, and you should only try and second guess the future at your peril.

 

Anne Marie English need I say more…

 

Now I’ve been through a few there but the one talent I’d like to draw your attention to is one Mr David Chung-Locater extraordinaire, a hugely useful talent and one with the least draw backs (IMHO)

 

So I’ve gone for Chung’s ability…but whos talent gets your vote?

Good points from you there Mr H.... After much ponderance, I reckon that David Chungs locating abilities would prove very useful indeed, been able to keep tabs of numerous individuals has already shown how helpfull to the rest of the gang it can be....

 

Emmmmm... I think if I was to choose, I'd go with Darcys talent, to have the hunch and be able to avoid potential disaster - surely this also helps the rest of the group!?

  • Author

But Darcy's talent doesn't work like that does it; it doesn't give him a heads up or let him know he's in for some bother.

It just makes sure he's not there when it gets a bit hairy, and it could be something as innocuous as the trots…

And you wouldn’t know until afterwards that it was his talent working.

I'm suprised you missed the Necroscope in your pro/con list Helm, the dead saved Harry's life loads of times by getting up for him and giving him invaluable information, like the equasions to the mobius continuum.

 

Thats got to be useful!

 

But on the other hand, using his talent by talking to Faother was what made him go visit him which turned him into a vamp but does that one big con out weigh all the pros?

  • 3 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 1 year later...
  • Author

I've decided after a long rest that the Mass Debate (chuckle) is due a return, for how long is up to you guy's as after all it's you lot who shall be putting your views accross.

Please refer to the begining of this thread for the rules etc.

 

So hopefully a week from now there will be loads of posts in here and from that I can choose us a new Mass Debater (more childish chuckling) who can set us a new topic for argument and genral discussion...

 

So what's the new topic to get us started???

 

The proposed Necroscope movie???

If you had the power how would you do it???

All star cast?

Bunch of knowbody's?

Would you stay completely faithful to the book?

Would you chang things completely to make them fit the medium of cinema better?

Would you condense more than one book into the story?

Would you even make it at all?

 

Remember there are a million and one way's to make a movie but how would you adapt this brilliant book?

 

Bare in mind constraints and budgets folks try and make your "pitch" as makeable as possible...

 

[ July 22, 2005, 03:10 AM: Message edited by: The Helm ]

My first thoughts on this would be to get Brian in as a consultant. No-one better than the author to visualize how "things" should look.

 

Maybe a couple of Big Names but try and get some good unknowns as well. (Maybe Tom Cruise to play Max Batu, thats about the only character he is tall enough to play smile.gif )

 

As to how...ah well.

 

I will think on this and post more later.... smile.gif

The last question seems the most apt, would I even make the film ? No ! Since I read the source back in the eighties Ive had a mental image of all the characters and the biggest problem with a film is our mental images are then replaced by actors so from that day on we no longer see the characters we "know", we see instead Brad Pitt, Antonio Banderas or Tom Cruise (are you sure ?)when we read our beloved books.

However though this question may be the most pertinent to me it is in fact the least relevant question as the film is already going ahead, so why did I bother answering it ? . . . . . . . I'll get my coat.

  • Author

The film is in fact only a proposed project and this in no way guarente's it being made...

 

And we are after your opinions so that would be why I would answer the question.

It's only a debate after all, it's not like were brainstorming for the film's production team now is it ;)

 

I think you'll find DC that Tom Cruise still is... smile.gif

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.